Transgender Regret-Happily NEVER After

A reader contacted me a few days ago regarding sharing her transition experiences with a greater audience, because up to now her feelings and her experiences around her transition where negative have not been at all welcome in her ( the Transgender) community. Unfortunately the Transgender community invests only in an All or Nothing narrative, the All being a sanguine version of Transition drugs, surgeries and familial/social experiences where reality isnt even allowed in the backseat.

This is a personal account of one person's transgender/transition experience, it may not be the lacquered version making headlines, but it is no less valid, in fact it is more:

I was born and raised as a female, and recall the first crush I had on a girl when I was 11 years old, she was my best friend in school. I suppressed these feelings, because at the time it was still illegal in the UK to discuss homosexuality in a positive way or to "promote" it. I didn't know anyone who was openly gay and happy, and so I responded with the heterosexual conditioning I had been raised with by society, and considered it wrong. Although I now largely prefer men, I recall strongly the confusion in my 11 year old self over liking a girl.

When I started puberty as a female, I began to feel discomfort in my body. I didn't like the breasts were developing, I didn't like periods, I didn't like how boys would make sexually suggestive comments and I didn't like the pressure from other girls, to be a girly girl. I wanted to remain a tomboy, which ultimately I did.

When I was 17, I joined an LGBT youth website. I very quickly discovered the trans section and began reading people's experiences. I read about people who never felt like girls, who wanted to be men. It felt like at the time, I had found the answer to what I was struggling with. I was a man trapped in a woman's body and that if I changed it, I would be happy and find peace with myself. At the age of 19, I saw a psychiatrist who specialised in gender identity disorders, who diagnosed me as a female to male transsexual. Throughout the entire process I didn't see a counselor or a therapist, to them it was box ticking. I started testosterone in 2011 and am still taking it today.

It wasn't until about two years ago, that I found a group on Facebook which was open to butches, femmes and trans men. For the first time in my life, I was around butch women who were proud of their butchness, who were proud to be butch women. Who took pride in their female bodies and in their lesbian identities. That was when I felt the first pangs of regret about the path I had gone down.

I have had the phalloplasty procedure to surgically construct a penis. The image I had in my head of what it would be, and how it is is completely different. The penis does not look like a "normal" penis and doesn't function like one. I have lost the use of my vagina for sex, because of a procedure they did to construct the urethra through the penis. I now have recurring urinary leakage problems due to the surgery. Risks that I was not made aware of.

I thought transition would bring me peace, it hasn't. I feel a bigger disconnect with my body now, than I ever did before I walked down that path. I am not suicidal and I am getting on well in life. But it feels strange to be seen as a man, because inside I still know I'm not. Since meeting those butch women, I feel an affinity to the term butch, even though I don't currently date women.

Perhaps if I had met those proud women when I was 17, I would have embraced my butch identity sooner and not felt the need to transition. I won't ever know.

At 17, I was not mature enough to make that decision and I personally feel that I was too young to start such a life and body altering process.

Not all trans stories are the happy endings that the trans community so carefully tries to present. There are some of us, like myself, who live in that silent regret, afraid to speak out publicly of their bad decision.



  1. this person only regrets because she never felt male in the first place. just like with all your 'regret examples', she feels regret because she made a decision to transition when she never actually wanted to. on the other side, trans men who DID feel like men, who feel like transitioning brought their bodies more in alignment with their minds, do not feel regret. you can literally google 'trans regret' to find sources showing the myth of trans regret being a large statistic.

  2. I am the anonymous author of this letter. And I agree completely with your first two sentences. No, I never felt male in the first place, and I regret the decision to transition as deep down I felt doubts on if I should or wanted to. The trans people I associated with at the time, made it very difficult to express these doubts, or even show signs of being gender variant but not identifying with being a binary man or woman trans person or identifying as trans full stop. I am speaking for myself and myself only and that I cannot express this to the trans communities I have previously associated with. I don't know the statistic for trans regret and while it may be relatively small, it still needs to be addressed and talked about. How do people like me, who aren't trans, come to make the decisions we do? What influences are we feeling pressure from to take this path? Our decision to transition despite not being trans do not form within a vacuum, there will always be external forces that influence these choices. Yes, I made the ultimate decision to transition, and that choice was mine alone. But I cannot deny that there were other circumstances which helped shape that choice, I didn't reach that point alone and that is something the trans community needs to be more willing to talk about. Because while a statistic even exists for this, then it's an issue to discuss. I can't undo my transition, but if I can help others who feel that transition may not be right for them by talking about this then I will.

    1. so why are you posting your anonymous story on a site that is run byba person who only enjoys your regret? if you want to help people dont let dirt use you to put others down. you made a mistake but there are loads of men who havent made a mistake. also i dont mean to be rude but as a person who has had all the proceedures your explanation of what happens is pretty poor. its more than one proceedure, and if you day you started t in 2011, which is a year before i did, the process to get on t and have top surgery and bottom surgery means you HAVE to see multiple therapists... the more i pick apart your story the more i realise that its probably written by a trans hating dyke by the name of dirt... do better research


Missing Person Kristin Snyder: Lost in a Sea of Myths Pt 4

Next up in our series on the The Lost Women of NXIVM mockumentary is Joseph O’Hara of Albany, NY. O'Hara was an attorney who worked fo...