Change Your World-NOT your Body

Tuesday, August 11, 2015

Trans Trending-Who is Transitioning

 Tomas-Age 20

Jay-Age 17

Max-Age 19

Ry-Age 17

Brad-Age 19

Alex-Age-16

Ell-Age 23

Lo-Age 17

GA-Age 20

Last week I received this in the email box connected with this blog:
Doing a quick bit of research this immediately popped up:
That Trans Trenders are so ill-equipped to handle even the most mildest (or any form) dissent begs us to ask why the Psychiatric/Medical Communities are giving them the big green light to transition? How fragile is this girl's psyche, if randomly running across a website, has thrown her into a suicidal quandary? Psychological assessments INSANELY do not factor into Gender Dysphoria diagnosis, merely tick boxing a small discriminatory check list. A check list created by/voted on what to include by the very same doKtors who diagnosed homosexuality as abnormal, cross dressing as abnormal, female promiscuity as abnormal, unwed mothers as abnormal, introversion as abnormal, transsexualism as abnormal, all at varying points in their careers!

There are two crucial issues here:
  • the first issue is the young women falling prey to transgenderism (most of which are lesbian) seem oblivious/ignorant of the brutal, violent and ugly history the Psychiatric community has with lesbians/females.
  • the second issue being the Psychiatric Community's direct focus on diagnosing Gender Dysphoria they are oblivious to the myriad of other psychosis Trans Trending female youth are suffering OR those that ARE being developed during transition.  
These girls arent the new men of 21 century progresses, they are young women seemingly MORE fragile and frightened than all women past. Their doKtors have let them fall under the assumption that if they blot out all that THEY feel makes them unhappy or insecure, happiness and security will will fall into their laps. Life is fraught with difficulties, misfortunes and tragedies, until we can smile in the face of that, we will be a stranger to both happiness and security. Something the young woman in question will remain, along with the young woman who reacted to her plight. Along with the women in this post.

dirt
 
Share:

55 comments:

  1. I disagree to some extent with your criticism of the psychiatric community. Sure, it has a horrible history of allowing very conservative social values to color perceptions of clinical diagnosis. But starting the in the 1970s it has been changing that trajectory (albeit very slowly).

    My impression is that the mental health field has lost its spine. The pendulum has swung in the opposite direction. The ridiculous social correctness surrounding all things trans has had a chilling effect on mental health providers.

    You are right that mental health providers are not pushing back, challenging misconceptions, and working with clearly fragile girls. I think the motive isn't as sinister as you suggest. Some are obviously greedy and see these stupid fad-driven kids (and their parents) as walking ATMs. Others are concerned but feel professionally constrained against pushing against the tide.

    What I would love most to see is real research into the underlying psych issues, specifically the relationships between trans and Autism Spectrum Disorder, personality disorders, Axis I disorders, and neurological studies (especially body-mapping functions). I think with good, hard science mental health providers would have an easier time with this.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Increasing the drugging of those who do not conform to societal norms are changes in the 70's I give you that. BUT they certainly, as can be seen everywhere arent for the better! Unless you count the deep deep pockets of Big Pharma better.

      dirt

      Delete
    2. There is ZERO correlation, obviously. Actual autistics are concerned with little outside themselves and unable to develop disorders arising from the Gender Straight Jacket/fetishes.

      dirt

      Delete
    3. I was referring to every day counselors and therapists rather than academic researchers or gender specialists. I worked for a lot of years with multiple psychiatric facilities and innumerable therapists of all sorts. Virtually all of them have no real ability to influence what the APA does.

      And I specifically referenced Autism Spectrum Disorder because there does appear to be a correlation. Many people has ASD to a degree and are capable of holding full-time jobs and everything else in life. They tend to lack a lot of social skills but they also tend to work in occupations where that is not super-important (i.e. IT, gaming, web design, general high tech, etc). It's not terribly mystifying that a lot of trans come from the tech industry. Also, there is some research to support this correlation, but like everything else trans there seems to be a fear of popping the trans bubble: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2904453/

      Delete
    4. Reasonable happy productive citizens shouldnt be diagnosed with mental illness PERIOD! What qualifies a female with ASD? Doing woman different, hence the LINK to trans. NOT because there is an organic link, BUT a SOCIAL one based fully on the Gender Straight Jacket!

      dirt

      Delete
    5. Well, we'll have to agree to disagree. I've spent 20 years working with mentally ill clients. People can have autism-related disorders and be quite productive. People can have bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, and many other disorders and be pretty productive. People can be good workers, great parents, and be very functional. Mental illness isn't experienced in non-stop crisis mode.

      One thing I think we can agree on is the need for ongoing research.

      Delete
  2. Anti-depressants saved my life, but this is a very different issue. There is a lot of research done on depression and its causes while there is absolutely no evidence for 'gender dysphoria.' Instead of talking with the patient and trying to figure out why they feel the way they feel, they prescribe dangerous drugs and surgeries. If we take BDD, anxiety, anorexia, depression or any other psychological disorder, there is always psychotherapy involved and drugs are seen as only a temporary solution to the problem. Why is 'gender dysphoria' treated differently? It makes me so angry...

    ReplyDelete
  3. "I disagree to some extent with your criticism of the psychiatric community. Sure, it has a horrible history of allowing very conservative social values to color perceptions of clinical diagnosis. But starting the in the 1970s it has been changing that trajectory (albeit very slowly).

    ...Sure, it has a horrible history of allowing very conservative social values to color perceptions of clinical diagnosis.

    The APA (American Psychological Association) collaberated with the Bush administration on its "enhanced interrogations". We are talking about waterboarding, prolonged sleep deprivation, and other forms of torture. The APA has crediblity.

    This experiment on children (GnRH agonists and/or cross gender hormones), 16 year old girls getting "top surgery" (elective mastectomies with the surgical trimming down of areolas and nipples, etc. could make lobotomies look good. Seriously, everyone knows that this transgender, "gender", cultural trend has gotten totally out of hand.

    You are right that mental health providers are not pushing back, challenging misconceptions, and working with clearly fragile girls. I think the motive isn't as sinister as you suggest.

    In Iran, the motive is sinister, and it's a form of gay and lesbian eugenics. Sinister is the only way to describe it. The same thing is going on in the U.S., albiet not as open and up front.

    ReplyDelete
  4. "The APA has crediblity."

    I meant to say "The APA has no credibility. sorry...

    ReplyDelete
  5. You conclude all based on what , an email and you call that research .... ? Well yes , you do , so what does that make you , some confused little bored teen who only knows how to get attention by talking of something you don't even understand , just to make up for the sad fact you got nothing going on in your own life . See how easy it is to do "research" on others . Greet ,Sam from the Netherlands .

    ReplyDelete
  6. My question is why are you using pictures of people you know nothing about, nor did you have permission to use them?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fuck no the bitch face didnt have fuckin permission!

      Delete
    2. I know. One of the guys in her list of pictures is a friend of mine, and had no clue his photo was being used

      Delete
    3. When people post their photos in public, they forego any rights to privacy regarding those photos. Want your privacy, don't publicly post photos bragging about your transition. Duh.

      Delete
    4. Anonymous 2:25 is correct. People need to carefully read a site's terms of service before posting anything on any site -- especially a site as public and as popular as Tumblr.

      Also, regarding copyright, there is "fair use," which states that "for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research,” copyrighted images may be used by those who are not the copyright holder.

      What it boils down to is that these f2t girls are willingly posting their own photos in public for anyone to see. Tumblr is a public website. No doubt Tumblr gets a lot more traffic than this little blog. Posting their own photos and all sorts of identifying information on Tumblr is what the teens and their parents should be worried about, not that the photos have been re-posted here.

      Honestly, though, for those who are so upset over this, Dirt is not calling these girls out because of hate. If I may be so presumptuous as to put words in her mouth, Dirt is trying to wake up the girls and their parents so they'll see that transition, especially in girls so young, can have devastating consequences down the road. Dirt wants these kids and their parents to make healthy, sane, smart decisions rather than jumping on the runaway train that is dangerous, medically unnecessary surgeries, cross-sex hormones and off-label use of GnRH agonists. Also, by showing list after list of these teens week after week, Dirt is illustrating to her readers just how prevalent the trans trend is currently among young females.

      Delete
  7. You are lucky I do not live in the same country and city you spiteful bitch. I'd blow my fucking brains out on your doorstep! Or better yet take your ugly sorry ass with me cunt!!!!!!!!!1

    btw I'm Bradley-the cute trans guy in the middle you choose to persecute on your shit stained blog paying your bills with. How does it feel to use guys in your community to finance your sorry fucking life bithc!

    suck balls and DIE!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There will always be the ones that stand against us brother. Don't let 1 person's demented view of you, change your view of yourself. Be the man you were created to be, stand strong and know that you are not alone.

      Delete
    2. She's about to blame the way you're speaking on testosterone, just watch. I usually just come here for a good laugh to see what kind of shit she's managed to scour up this week.

      Delete
    3. Lol @ Bradley. Threatening suicide is Abuser Logic 101. Maybe that works with making mommy and daddy let you chop your boobs off, but it isn't going to work with adults who care about the widespread exploitation of emotionally injured children.

      Plus, it sounds like you have a LOT of anger issues. Maybe you should seek some professional help for your anger management.

      Delete
    4. Abusive men are not good role models. Lashing out with threats, swearing, etc. is very weak way to argue or persuade. We need less men in the world like this, not more. If you are trying to cross the gender divide don't perpetuate male violence, esp. against women.

      Delete
  8. I believe this blog is being reported for posting photos of minors without permission. Hopefully other kids won't be subject to unwillingly having their photos posted here by an unconventional predator.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. All pictures are public and linked for credit.

      dirt

      Delete
    2. But why do you post it at all?

      Delete
    3. I'm not Dirt, but see my reply above, from August 13 at 11:03 p.m. Calling these kids out is a way to encourage these teens and their parents to wake up! The medical establishment is willingly harming and sterilizing kids. There is no research which proves transitioning kids is safe, or that it helps these kids become happy adults.

      Delete
  9. Its a bummer ain't it?
    The way one can't pick and choose where ones image goes when posting it : ONLINE IN PUBLIC FORMATS.
    Entitlement is like ice cream; it doesn't travel well.
    So here lets explain it one more time....
    When you put your little YouTube shows on, or that Special Just Right Selfie, in hopes of trading standing up to pee tricks, or a compliment about your new doo, it goes out into cyberspace and you don't get to demand permission to use it, or control others thoughts. Got it now? Maybe??

    ReplyDelete
  10. "in hopes of trading standing up to pee tricks"

    Oh for god's sake, any woman can stand up to pee; you don't have to be a man to do that. It's not rocket science.

    http://home.earthlink.net/~instructions/sp.htm

    ReplyDelete
  11. What's the deal with the douche "guy" facial expression, that is commonly assumed for selfies by these FTT ?

    The raised eyebrow + smirk = Justin Beiber, that son of Will Smith's, etc. - underage, contemptuous, uneducated narcissists. This is a facial expression that I would cross the street to avoid - as the wearer is typically the worst kind of asshole, who will lay some toxic "joking" comment on any woman who crosses his path.

    Who are these FTT's role models anyway ? Why is the "masculinity"masquerade of the worst sort ? There are many men who are artists, scientists, writers, etc. - not the typical "dudes" - who could actually be progressive role models ?

    I'd like to escape the gender straightjacket, too, but see no value in a minstrel show as Beiber, Fred Durst, or Donald Trump.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And it's not like they really escaped any gender straightjacket, they just jumped into the dude one. Trans are so horribly conservative and backwards regarding gender.

      It's sorta funny how none of these transguys really look like guys. They still all look really femme.

      Delete
    2. I've only had male role models and I want to be a scientist. Even though I do feel pressure relating to gender, especially with this whole trans trend, I learned I had to work through it because I realized no scientist in their right mind would transition. We value truth and logic, and dedicate our lives to it. It would just be so laughable.

      Delete
  12. You all make me want to vomit down your throats with your bigoted comments.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I've been following this blog for a while and although i don't agree with alot of it or the way dirt posts these kids photos i could see what she was trying to say in her posts, now the comment dirt wrote saying autistic people (like myself) are "concerned with little outside ourselves and unable to develop disorders outside the gender straight jacket" wtf? As an autistic woman that has struggled with gender/sex dysphoria for years I'm telling you that 1. You don't speak for autistic people 2. There IS a connection between autism and transgenderism. I would keep going but its late and i have work in the morning (yes us autistics can hold down jobs and follow hobbies and intrests outside ourselves, hard to believe i know!) and one more thing if you really wanted to help people and get them to take you seriously then first you should stop posting their pictures (no one would want to see their face on this site and you're doing nothing good by it) and stop posting trans porn (whats that all about? Theres no need for it.
    If you want to have your views taken seriously then stop targeting these (mostly teenaged) individuals and putting their pictures and surgery pictures on your site because your site is not providing real info other then your opinion on transpeople and your conspiracy theories about how you think lesbians are being forcefully transitioned. Your not doing anything to help people and your information about transition is not very factual (like assuming a person has cancer as a result of their transition and not considering other factors)

    Maybe you had intended to provide information when you started this page but its turned into a site that just bashes people and goes on about those that don't think the same as you as being brainwashed, mentally ill or suffering from internalized misogyny. You're obsessed with transpeople and i am understanding more and more why people have such negative opinions of you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That you just typed that online illustrates are arent autistic. Being diagnosed via DSM's new world wide net, doesnt an autistic make. Communication of any kind is rare among true autistics.

      dirt

      Delete
    2. You obviously have little understanding of autism if thats what you think someone must be like to be autistic. Autism is not only behavioural, its neurological.
      Maybe getting diagnosed for things (including transgenderism) is easy in your country but its very difficult in mine, they don't just hand out diagnosis easily.

      Delete
    3. Hey Dirt. I like a lot of what you do, but I think you need to do more learning about autism spectrum disorders. Here is a study where it was indicated that there was a much higher incidence of Gender Identity Disorder in children and adolescents with ASD:

      http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2904453/

      Delete
    4. Different study suggests higher numbers of autism spectrum disorders in FTT:

      http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/05/110505103241.htm

      Delete
  14. "I believe this blog is being reported for posting photos of minors without permission"

    When this Dr. Mengele like experiment on children (sterilizing children, mutilating their bodies) comes crashing down, no one can say that people weren't warned.

    We are commenting on a culturally phenomenon. The internet is saturated with FTM and transgender blogs. Google FTM, and there are 26,200,000 results. When I type in "transgender" into the Google search box, I get 81 million links.

    (1.) Why are 16 and 17 year old girls getting free breast binders from transgender organizations? It's not like they don't know breast binding can mis-align ribs and cause other health problems.

    (2.) Why are 14, 15, and 16 year old girls posting youtbue video after youtube video of where to get "T", breast binders, and when and where can I get "top surgery"? Do their parents know what they are doing?

    (3.) Why are transgender organizations pushing GnRH agonists (puberty suppression) on parents and children? Children who go from the GnRH agonists to cross gender hormones are rendered infertile. Sterilizing children is a human rights abuse.

    (4.) In this article, an 11 year old male child is given female hormones. Also, a 14 year old female child is given testosterone. One year later, she got her breasts removed.

    http://www.houstoniamag.com/articles/2014/11/3/what-do-transgender-children-need-november-2014

    This is freaking child abuse.

    ReplyDelete
  15. No you assholes don't know anything about the trans people. You need a shrink instead of trying to make someone think your way. It isn't your life, moron! Live and let live. Get a life of your own. If you don't believe in this fine. Shut the fuck up and leave it alone. You are bigotted hateful people. besides you can't do anything about it. Of course you could go out and beat someone up. Where would that leave you? In jail as someone's bitch. And the person you hate will be free and living thier lives anyway. grow up!

    ReplyDelete
  16. How the hell is it child abuse if these are licensed doctors who are screening them, councilling them,etc? You just think that way because it goes against your beleif system. Or that this embarrasses YOU? Sorry but it isn't about YOU at all or how you think things are supposed to be. If this was your kid with a cleft lip, you would be rushing down to get it fixed. This is no different. Get educated before you judge this. It is out of your scope of practice to write this off as child abuse. These doctors are experts in thier field.. If you have a heart ailment you go a heart specialist. Not to a to a podiotrist. Same here. You go to a licensed gender specialist which you can legally find in any major city.BTW. This isn't goimg away because you think it should. Get used to it.It doesn't effect YOU.

    ReplyDelete
  17. The doctors know a Hell of a lot more than you ignorant people do. Stick to what you know. go join the conservative KKK party you assholes!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Yes Bennett, the medical industry knows exactly what they are doing, and your willful ignorance is a textbook example of why they are enabled to do it.

    ReplyDelete
  19. @Bennett Marco,

    The APA, the largest organization of psychologists in the U.S., collaberated with the Bush administration on its "enhanced interrogations". The information is out there. They have no credibility. The "gender dysphoria" b.s. that they are peddling to naive parents and people is a cash cow for "gender therapists", Big Pharma (hella $$$ in puberty suppressing drugs, etc.), and plastic surgeons.

    The APA knows diddly, and they have no crediblity left. It shouldn't surprise people that the APA collaberated with the Bush administration on its "enhanced interrogations" (waterboarding, sleep deprivation, etc.). In the former Soviet Union, political dissidents were locked away in mental hospitals. In Iran, psychologists and psychiatrists are involved in a form of gay and lesbian eugenics in which gay men and lesbians get their genitals mutilated and are told that they are really members of the opposit sex. Psychiatry is no better than the APA. They gave us lobotomies and shock treatment.

    The doctors know a Hell of a lot more than you ignorant people do.

    (1.) History is littered with examples of ghastly experiments that went horribly wrong. The list is too long to post here. At the time, people really thought they were doing the right thing, and some of these ghoulish experiments were even lauded as miracle cures.

    (2.) If doctors know everything there is to know, then why are they covering their ass by having patients sign an Informed Consent form? People can get cross gender hormones without a letter from a therapist.

    They all but admit that this is an experiment on otherwise healthy female bodies. It's even in the" Informed Consent Form for Testosterone Therapy". They want to cover their ass, and this is why they say the following:

    (initial the box) "I understand that testosterone can be converted to estrogen by various tissues in my body, and that it is not known whether this increases the risks of ovarian cancer, breast cancer, or uterine cancer."

    When a female checks the boxes and signs the form, she is basically saying that she will be part of this experiment.

    http://studenthealth.oregonstate.edu/sites/studenthealth.oregonstate.edu/files/main/docs/consent_testosterone_therapy.pdf

    (3.) I really have problems with sterilizing children with GnRH agonists and/or cross gender hormones. Transgender sources always say they are reversible, but this is only partly true. Kids who go from GnRH agonists to cross gender hormones are rendered infertile. Pumping a kid full of cross gender hormones before their bodies have the time to mature renders them infertile Sterilizing children is a human rights abuse. Besides the fertility issue, I doubt that people know the long term effects of these drugs. This is the same class of drugs that are used for advanced prostate cancer and endometriosis.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Being autistic is the new It Thing.
    "I'm Autistic! I'm a misunderstood, marginalized Gifted Savant!

    There are fake autistic people popping up all over social media which is oxymoronic.
    Its also deeply offensive to the struggles Real Autistic Persons have.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And for those of us who have grown up with those who are born with real autism, this current look-at-me-im-so-special-ASDed, it's a sickening fucking insult!

      Delete
    2. My g/f and I and most all of our closest friends and loved ones could easily be diagnosed with this current ASD nonsense. And we are a far cry from autistic, as is obvious by the fact alone that I'm writing this back/effectively communicating.

      Delete
    3. If you need/rely on the psychiatric comm to tell you you have a problem, then you have a TOTALLY different problem.

      Delete
    4. If you need/rely on the psychiatric comm to tell you you have a problem, then you have a TOTALLY different problem.

      Delete
    5. My g/f and I and most all of our closest friends and loved ones could easily be diagnosed with this current ASD nonsense. And we are a far cry from autistic, as is obvious by the fact alone that I'm writing this back/effectively communicating.

      Delete
  21. You can put on little YouTube Shows, create little Bieber Fuck Yeah Clubs, throw breast binder giveaway benefits and Go Fund Me, come Date Me, Please Rate Me, Watch me do porn and fap away to me, and communicate and babble in an endless pageantry of intrapersonal exchanges.

    And so, now you're all autistic, too.

    BULLSHIT. AS USUAL.

    ReplyDelete
  22. And IT IS OUR BUSINESS BECAUSE WE ARE FEMINISTS AND ANYTHING INVOLVING WOMEN WE MAKE OUR BUSINESS.

    There are sisters and daughters being sucked into a misogynist OZ that we will not close our eyes to. Are you kidding? WE'RE DYKES FFS. We are among the strongest, most articulate people in the world. We are taking our kesbian children and our Tomboys BACK.

    Those of you who are too far gone into this trend, take your synthetic "T" while the supply is hot. Wear your choker necklaces and ballcaps that have never seen a field. You think we hate you - YOUR WRONG. When you are no longer able to pass as tiny teenage boy, when you are frail and don't have a single fuck yeah in you, all of your scars and missing places and consequences will be overlooked and you will have a safe place to heal. Because we are feminists and we won't shut our door to women.
    If by chance you entertain the thought of creating your own sanctuary amongst each other once reality hits. - by all means do so.

    But the male world you have mutilated yourself for will have nothing for you. You are emulating those who will never see you as there own. And that, is putting it extremely mildly.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, shut the fuck up, you psychotic bitch.
      It has nothing to do with misogyny, these ridiculous transmen related posts are the epitome of delusional. Get a life instead of concerning yourself with whats in our pants.

      Delete
    2. It's funny when they're talking about misogyny when they're claiming that all female bodied people are "tiny and frail". How's that hatred of women going for you?

      Delete
    3. Man you Anonymi are pretty stupid, "you psychotic bitch... It has nothing to do with misogyny"
      "all female bodied people are 'tiny and frail'"
      So the first idiot has severe internalized misogyny to the point that a disagreeing woman is a psychotic bitch and should shut the fuck up while the second has reading comprehension problems (hint: older people are more frail than younger people on average).

      Delete
  23. There was no such comment stating that all females are tiny and frail.
    Please read again without the typical warp of perspective.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thank you Anon 3:01 for clarifying - it is tough to get through what seems like a signature odd filter of no comprehension. But thanks for the helpful emphasis your comment provided.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Well, you don't need to be fragile to feel hurt by all the insults here. Anyone affected would feel hurt if they'd read they are abnormal, faking their problems to catch attention, not able to think by themselves, or even called "trans trends" the same way a lesbian would feel hurt to hear that, anyway, love between two girls can't exist because there is no penis (I don't think that at all, it's just a review I had read on a french website someday) or a woman would be hurt to hear that she is not as valuable as a man because of her sex (Same here, this is none of my own belief). What I mean is you don't need to be fragile to feel offended by everything wrote on your website and it can lead to suicide the same way homophobia and homophobic harassment can lead gays and lesbians to suicide.
    (Despite I think it's violent, I can keep some distance with all the offending things you write about trans people and I'm not really touched. But some of the comments are really hard to read, trust me. You may not like us but you and your readers could at least be respectfull and it begins with stop posting these photos).

    ReplyDelete

Copyright © The dirt from Dirt | Powered by Blogger
Design by SimpleWpThemes | Blogger Theme by NewBloggerThemes.com | Distributed By Blogger Templates20