Change Your World-NOT your Body

Tuesday, January 28, 2014

Without Pronouns Transgender Vanishes

The Gender Straight Jacket continues to reach a greater strangulation grip and new levels of amentia. Last year a trans male (female fetishizer) Essay Anne Vanderbilt Stephen Krol killed himself. His suicide was blamed on an article that was due to be published, potentially uncovering both his fraudulent familial and scientific credentials as well as his sex. This man's death has sparked a violent stream of attacks on the author of the article and a brainstorming of how to better accommodate the Trans community's finicky pronoun usage in and out of print by the PC police.

While this post isnt specifically about Krol's suicide, I will say only a few brief things on the subject.

 1) Both the Medical and Trans community bear some responsibility for this man's death. Both communities lead mentally unhealthy minds into believing that their social transitions will be as straight forward as their cosmetic transitions. It was no secret that Krol had tried suicide in the past and had a history of depression pre and post transition. It was well known also that rather than try and integrate his transition into the life he had lived for 50 years as a mechanic, husband of several women and father of two, Krol simply told the general public his family were all killed in a car accident. These are not the thoughts or actions of a mentally healthy person. The medical community should have put him into a long term treatment program before even considering transition and the Trans community should have been/be more transparent about just how unsmooth and unsuccessful social transition is. Both communities should have also reiterated that transition is about feeling better with ones body, regardless of what anyone else in the world thinks or says.

2) One of things that came out of the Stonewall movement was a majority agreement from gays and lesbians on how crucial "coming out" out was to gay and lesbian visibility. Showing that through visible numbers, we were everywhere and a force to be reckoned with. Made even more important when "coming out" was from those in places of high visibility or power. Of the gay and lesbian progresses from 1969 till today, those progresses were and continue to be because of a greater gay and lesbian visibility due to being "out" and "proud" and in all levels of society. The gay and lesbian community at large has also held the position of "outing" those closeted gays or lesbians in power positions, especially when against gay/lesbian progress. When gays and lesbians are still routinely bashed or worse, it makes a HUGE difference in the minds of the general straight public when they find out their favourite film or tv star/political leader/sports figure etc comes out as gay/lesbian or is outed as such. Being out/outed continues to be a prime changer in the progress of gay and lesbian rights and treatment. The Gay and Lesbian movement didnt invite the Trans community to the party, but it has supported them, even putting its out needs many times on the back burner. Being a apart of the Gay and Lesbian movement means being visible, out and proud, that goes for gay men, lesbians and every trans person wanting to remain part of our movement. There is an unspoken rule in this community necessary for a continued progress in straight society, thats out, loud and proud, and if you're not, ya might just find yourself outed. Welcome to our Gay and Lesbian community!

Now back to what gave rise to this post in the first place. The ever angry attacking Trans mob has so many folks in fits of fear over the insane politics of the Political Correctness of every atom that MIGHT fall into its field of Transgenderism vision, articles like this are popping up all over the net! All tripping over their own tongues with apologies whenever a wrong pronoun is used when referring to a trans male or trans female by mistake. Or trying to find, like the linked article above, an asexual pronoun they can use in place of he/him/his/she/her/hers. I realise most truly believe they are trying to help and not offend those in the constant state of transition, but their knowledge of transition, its past and present are nil as this article plainly illustrates.

If lets say, sex was suddenly removed from all languages, poof-gone. Now at first it would take a minimum of time to get used to, but the obviousness of the sexes would quickly reestablish itself with its presence. The truth is, most of us do not require an F or an M on our ID's, our clothing areas, our pronouns etc, most of us are secure enough in our biology that if sex were removed from language we would still function much as we today, including those of us whose sex is ambiguous or invisible.

But to the fragile (trans) mind that has settled on a HE or a SHE despite basic biology? They couldnt exist, period! If suddenly there were no transma(e)n or transwoma(e)n, no male to female or female to male, no male or no female. Because transition cosmetically mimics biology, if biology itself replaced language and all associated with it, trans could not exist. This is why we see the torrent of viscous verbal threats and attacks from the Trans community on anyone, especially feminists who insist on common sense biology and centuries of established language associated with biology. Because within those realms, the trans self created/deluded paid for identity cannot exist. Therefore creating a set of pronouns to replace sexed pronouns isnt a solution to the trans pronoun problem, it is the end of trans altogether.

If you were ever in doubt at all about the authenticity of trans, this post should clear it up for you. Simply, if you cannot stand alone on your biology; without clothing, without pronouns, without bathrooms, without names, without toys, without every external in the world, then you're not standing at all.

dirt


Share:

13 comments:

  1. It was quite an elaborate collection of fabrications from the beginning. I feel sorry for the loss of this person, but why the deception.

    "It was well known also that rather than try and integrate his transition into the life he had lived for 50 years as a mechanic, husband of several women and father of two, Krol simply told the general public his family were all killed in a car accident. These are not the thoughts or actions of a mentally healthy person."

    "She didn’t want to integrate into her new life her past as a mechanic, as a husband to two women and as a father to two boys and a girl who still lived in Pennsylvania. She later told Jordan her family had died in a tragic accident." (the ex-wife and three children all died in an accident - not true)

    "Over the years, Vanderbilt told people she had worked on the Stealth Bomber (not true) as a private contractor for the Department of Defense, (not true) that she had earned an MBA from the Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania (not true) and that she had attended MIT to become a physicist. (not true)

    http://www.azcentral.com/community/gilbert/articles/20140124gilbert-golf-inventor-suicide-website-essay-anne-vanderbilt.html?nclick_check=1

    As he reported, Hannan later wrote, he tried but could not verify those credentials. He never found an explanation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree that the p.c. thought police have gotten out of hand. They do pitch a hissy fit if anyone is "mi-sgendered". In my opinion, it's a shame how mainstream media have been harangued and brow beat into politically correct submission with all the pronoun usage. If we don't refer to a male who still has male genitalia as "she" if he states he "feels like a woman inside" (never mind the penis), we are horrid bigots. Actually, worse than bigots.

    It is also idiot and flies in the face of logic and common sense when this p.c. madness conflicts with a transgender individual's past history. Even when they were married to women and fathered several children with past wives, they are terribly offended if they are referred to as he. The wives and children seem to disappear. Males impregnate women and females become pregnant and give birth. That is, in the real world not the pretty, pink unicorn transgender fantasy world.

    We could stop this madness if we wanted to. All we have to do is stop referring to males as "she" or females as "he". There is nothing they could do about it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. "But to the fragile (trans) mind that has settled on a HE or a SHE despite basic biology? They couldnt exist, period! If suddenly there were no transma(e)n or transwoma(e)n, no male to female or female to male, no male or no female. Because transition cosmetically mimics biology, if biology itself replaced language and all associated with it, trans could not exist. This is why we see the torrent of viscous verbal threats and attacks from the Trans community on anyone, especially feminists who insist on common sense biology and centuries of established language associated with biology. Because within those realms, the trans self created/deluded paid for identity cannot exist. Therefore creating a set of pronouns to replace sexed pronouns isnt a solution to the trans pronoun problem, it is the end of trans altogether."

    Without gender (everything associated with sex based stereotypes, pronouns, "he", "she", etc.), transgender wouldn't exist. Biological males dressing in a manner associated with stereotypical images of what a "woman" is supposed to be doesn't mean that they are female. It just means they are males with a different way of doing things and dressing.



    ReplyDelete
  4. Another wild fabrication...

    "When Jordan and Vanderbilt met and started dating in 2006, Vanderbilt described herself using the word intersex. Intersex means a person is born with sex chromosomes, external genitalia or an internal reproductive system that is not standard for either male or female.

    “She would never even say that to me, that she was a trans person,” said Jordan. “She would say she was intersex, and that’s different. To her, that was different. "

    http://www.azcentral.com/community/gilbert/articles/20140124gilbert-golf-inventor-suicide-website-essay-anne-vanderbilt.html?nclick_check=1

    The way that transgender activists and others have shamelessly co-opted intersex is, in my opinion, offensive to people who have actual disorders of sexual development. Every major intersex organization makes a distinction between intersex and transgender. Intersex (disorders of sexual development) are actual genetic and medical conditions whereas transgender is an umbrella term for people who think and feel a certain way. In essence, it's psychological not physical. It's highly unlikely that Vanderbilt was intersex. Many people with actual disorders of sexual development are infertile. Vanderbilt was married to two women and was a father of three children.

    I feel sorry for the family, and for the loss of this individual. Having said this, with the long list of lies, he had to have known that he would be discovered sooner or later.

    ReplyDelete
  5. fuck yea! this post is so true. the transgender ideology is so superficial! its mostly perpetuated by strong-arming others with the weapon of politically correctness. For real, if we didnt have pronouns, if they couldnt "define" themselves, this issue would disappear! genius.

    ReplyDelete
  6. "If lets say, sex was suddenly removed from all languages, poof-gone. Now at first it would take a minimum of time to get used to, but the obviousness of the sexes would quickly reestablish itself with its presence. The truth is, most of us do not require an F or an M on our ID's, our clothing areas, our pronouns etc, most of us are secure enough in our biology that if sex were removed from language we would still function much as we today, including those of us whose sex is ambiguous or invisible."

    Actually, only a minority of the world's languages use gendered pronouns. Grammatical gender is characteristic of Indo-European (Spanish, Hindi...) and Afro-Asiatic (Hebrew, Arabic...).
    But speakers of Uralic languages like Finnish or Hungarian, Turkish or any of the dozens of Turkic languages spoken from the Mediterranean to Siberia, Chinese in all its varieties or virtually any Amerindian language, know no equivalent of the he/she/it distinction or other grammatical features that separate males and females linguistically into separate categories.
    And yet they are as vividly aware of both their biological sex and their sociological gender as we are, and their societies are not noticeably less sexist than our own.

    So Dirt does not actually need to take us on this thought-experiment. The point she is making already stands, as observable linguistic and sociological fact.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Tiny point - I believe in Chinese that the way you refer to yourself (i.e. say me) reflects your position in society relative to who you are speaking to. It has an element of gender in it.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks so much for pointing out the responsibility to help people like Dr. V/Krol rather than just giving them hormones and surgery. No doubt Dr. V had mental health issues before transitioning, but they were ignored. That is one of the fall-outs of calling gender dysphoria an identity rather than an illness.

    Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Without pronouns, lesbians vanish too, Dirt.

    ReplyDelete
  10. "I believe in Chinese that the way you refer to yourself (i.e. say me) reflects your position in society relative to who you are speaking to."

    Your humble servant thanks you for this information (-:

    ReplyDelete
  11. Without pronouns, lesbians vanish too, Dirt.

    Homosexuality has existed for as long as Homo sapiens have existed. It existed in ancient Greece. Moreover, same sex sexual behavior has been observed in primates and most mammals. Of course, they can't say they are gay or lesbian, but we can observe the behavior.

    Primates, both human and non-human, do not change their sex.




    ReplyDelete
  12. If transgender vanishes, you and Dirt have nothing in your lives.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Sounds like he may have been a pathological liar/sociopath. I dated one of these types for two years.

    ReplyDelete

Copyright © The dirt from Dirt | Powered by Blogger
Design by SimpleWpThemes | Blogger Theme by NewBloggerThemes.com | Distributed By Blogger Templates20