Change Your World-NOT your Body

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Hate Speech, Slander and Ignorance from Trans Australia

Seems Trans Australia is trying to utilize FaceBook to have my blog "removed" from Blogger by staging an "event" to "lets get dirt's transphobia banned". Not only is this group ignorant of what my blog actually espouses, they are also quite ignorant of US laws and the First Amendment. Australians, I suggest you brush up on your US history! And yes, I did report this hate group to Blogger so that Blogger is fully aware of this hate group's malecentric silencing tactics. If you would like to report this hate group to FaceBook, email me and I will link you.



dirt

Edit to add-seems they are employing LiveJournal to spread their hate as well.

ps Please do not judge all trans people by this ignorance and hate.
Share:

50 comments:

  1. i totally agree with them your a slag and i hope you die.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank God for the United States of America where the teenaged tranny taliban can't silence free speech. So typical of the male-identified to try to silence women, and to try to call in "authority figures" to do so. What a lame bunch of kids. Sad.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's entirely in your own faculties to say what you want to say on this blog, and so are Stormfront racists on theirs.

    That said, and even considering the fact I don't always agree with you, if those people thought your blog was uniquely "transphobic" or "making fun of FTMs", then they clearly haven't read it very well or deliberately choose to misread it to hide some uncomfortable pieces of truth (I don't think you are the Mouth of Truth TM, but your "common" sense in certain issues is badly needed in this age of queer academias).
    And then those whiney trans people (not all of them luckily) will WHINE BAWWWWWW until they get what they want, like little children who can't face the world on their own and need a "mommy" (under the guise of "stopping the hatred") to protect them.
    Hey, black people on Stormfront are very well capable of defending themselves, and showing the racists who's right.

    ReplyDelete
  4. "DIE BITCH DIE!!"

    ...I was saying, they can WHINE BAWWW when they have to be in politically correct spaces or STFU WOMAN GTFO U UGLY ASS DYKE. The latter, I guess, makes them seem more macho to their own eyes, while it just makes them seem violently retarded.

    ReplyDelete
  5. If they really wanted to stop "hate speech" they'd be harassing Fred Phelps. Looks like you really hit a nerve Dirt. Keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Blue,

    Dont insult retarded people with the comparison. I have a 70 y/o mildly retarded brother who has more common sense then the lot of these kids put together.

    dirt

    ReplyDelete
  7. Sorry, I used it because "retard" is probably the most common e-nsult ("Guy is a retard because he likes Green Day"), but it's just as offensive as "gay" (as in, this pen doesn't work, it's sooo gay).

    On the other hand, this doesn't excuse their own lack of neuron use!

    ReplyDelete
  8. It is astounding to me that people can't distinguish between "hate speech" and people who disagree with them and their worldview. It's never hate speech to disagree with someone and point out the flaws in their logic.

    How weird that people who are upset with you for what they see as "hate speech" come here and write that they hope you die, etc. That is actual hate speech, because it doesn't engage in thoughtful reasoned debate; it's pure hate instead.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I don't understand international law very well, but I think a country can ban a US website if they get a court order from their own jurisdiction. Like China/Korea often block US websites. I think they could block people in Ausfailia from reading your blog, but it would still be visibile everywhere else (like here in the US).

    I could be wrong, but I think that's how it works.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Anon@1:09pm

    I think before one involves "intl law" one could take into account there on everyone's computer there is this little button that when you press it, turns your computer and "offending" website off.

    If you are so mentally fragile that you cannot refrain from going to websites that anger you, you should not have internet access.

    dirt

    ReplyDelete
  11. Trans people like this give me a headache and make the very few half way decent trans identified people look bad. Maybe the truth should come out about what they do to each other within their community; talk about hate speech and bullying.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Dirt,

    some trans people support you because we think you have the right to have a different opinion than ours ! And because your blog is good at warning those girls who transition just because it is the fad and who harm us more...

    Please don't stop ! You do a great job by offering us interesting point of view !

    ReplyDelete
  13. HE. not SHE. stop disrespecting people's personal transitions and feelings, and their fucking entire lives.

    how the fuck would you feel if a femme started a blog saying that all butch lesbians aren't real women cause they want to dress like men and have short haircuts. you wouldn't like it. and you sure as hell would be pissed if they posted photos of you, and defaming you. putting shame to your name.

    you ignorant piece of shit. i hope a bunch of transguys find out where you live and beat the shit out of you.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Ash said:
    "HE. not SHE. stop disrespecting people's personal transitions and feelings, and their fucking entire lives".

    You may subscribe to the trans delusion Ash, but I however do not. If they were actually men, we wouldnt be here now.

    "how the fuck would you feel if a femme started a blog saying that all butch lesbians aren't real women cause they want to dress like men and have short haircuts. you wouldn't like it. and you sure as hell would be pissed if they posted photos of you, and defaming you. putting shame to your name".

    No Femme would do that, so that isnt an issue, Femmes and Butches support each other, understand each other, respect each other, love each other and most importantly SEE each other. Soceity may not, and the only shame is on them.

    "you ignorant piece of shit. i hope a bunch of transguys find out where you live and beat the shit out of you".

    Not only would it take a "bunch of transguys" it would also take their dads and brothers, i.e. some real men. And if you would like my address Ash, just email me hun. But be sure to call before you come over, I dont wanna waste my precious time waiting downstairs for you, when you dont show up.

    dirt

    ReplyDelete
  15. @ Dirt:

    "No Femme would do that, so that isnt an issue, Femmes and Butches support each other, understand each other, respect each other, love each other and most importantly SEE each other."

    Sorry, but that's not been my experience at all. When I lived in Los Angeles for a while, the lesbians all seemed to be femme, and they wanted nothing to do with and seemed embarrassed by my butch ass. Also as a young person growing up in Seattle, all dykes were butch, and if you were femme you weren't considered a lesbian.

    I'm afraid that your little fantasy world of all femmes loving and respecting all butches and vice versa might exist only in your mind.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Femme and feminine are two very different things, as is "butch" and Butch.

    Femmes only date Butch lesbians, they arent going to attack those they are attracted to.

    dirt

    ReplyDelete
  17. thanks guys for inviting me to get the dirt bitch cunt whore banned. but what we rilly need tado is kill this bitch dead. hope you rot in fucking hell slut!

    ReplyDelete
  18. As a journalism major, and aware of slander and libel, I think that your blog isn't in breach of these things. Even if these topics or pictures you posted were in publications, it still adheres to the 1st Amendment and Journalistic credo.

    I don't understand why if you disagree with FTM transitions for valid reasons- it's transphobic?

    Things I dislike about the FTM community:

    The aggressiveness.
    I don't know if it' all the testosterone, but these FTM's are aggressive and attacking. They live on the internet, one misstep of calling an FTM a she, and it's cause for hatred and nasty messages.

    They're hypocritical. They post a video everyday about their facial hair updates, how they can't wait to grow a "dick", brag about all the "straight women they're going to fuck" and post misogynistic pornography all over their tumblr's and what not...
    but bash this informed and educated blog for voicing truths they refuse to recognize.

    Testosterone injections are dangerous. Anything that affects your physiological makeup, changes your brain... has to have side effects... try to tell them this and they call you TRANSPHOBIC! I can't stand it.

    Meanwhile, more men are coming into the world helping to create a place obsessed with masculinity, pornography, and helping to demean women.

    What's worse is that these FTM's used to be women but show such great disrespect of women. They aren't gentle men, at least the ones I know. They're misogynistic beings obsessed.

    What's sad is that some of these FTM's were great musicians artists and free spirited women once and they've become so obsessed with growing a soul patch they don't do music anymore. Or they've given up their singing voice for an engorged clitoris and deeper voice.

    I don't understand this phenomenon. And your blog helps. It's not afraid to stand up to ignorance and speak the truth.

    With all this said, I do want to state that I believe in Transexualism. I have known true transexuals my entire life, and most of these girls aren't. 4 Years ago they were the same girls that tried to dress like Shane on the Lword. Using Ilene Chaiken's show as a bouncing board for their sexuality.

    That's what this is. And the thing that angers me the most is that once they do this, once they spend this money, inject these drugs, mutilate their bodies, file the proper paper work and are recognized as the opposite sex, they are allowed to MARRY.
    FTM transexuals will be allowed to marry as long as it's a person of the opposite sex they identify with.

    Is this what we have to do? THIS? You speak of how transexualism was created to eradicate homosexuality. There you go. They are considered a heterosexual couple and granted rights that I might never have.

    Forgive me if I want to keep my breasts and fight the good fight- and stick it out with my hottass girlfriend in my biological body.

    Quitters.

    ReplyDelete
  19. JUST THE FACT THAT A PERSONAL BLOG INCITES DEATH THREATS FROM THE TRANS COMMUNITY SHOULD BE AN INDICATOR THAT THIS COMMUNITY SUBSCRIBES TO MISOGYNY AND THAT TESTOSTERONE AFFECTS YOUR BRAIN, AND YOUR JUDGEMENT. WTF.

    ReplyDelete
  20. No worries Anon, all threats, the tumbl link, livejournal link and the facebook link have all been reported to my local FBI office for slander, hate speech, threats and bullying and the facebook page has a list of real names of folks, thank god for stupid people.

    dirt

    ReplyDelete
  21. DIRT ALERT spotted dirt at the kroger at 13 and woodward in royal oak, 6pm tonight followed her around for a min said hi she flat out ignored me, maybe because all she had in her basket was about 4 bottles of KY and some powdered eggs..... wtf i need 2 know WHY the FUCKIN powdered eggs?

    ReplyDelete
  22. Dear Anonymous-


    I asked her to pick those things up for me at the store.
    I'm baking your mother, Dorothy Mantooth, a cake.

    And speaking of Dorothy, I'm going to have to speak to her about your manners. Following people around is rude.

    Sb.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thank you for adding the ps at the end. That gave me a bit of a smile.

    ReplyDelete
  24. [Maybe the truth should come out about what they do to each other within their community; talk about hate speech and bullying.]

    I have actually been one of the singular voices in calling out the trans community for its hypocrisy and victimization complex. The other side still feels that I'm a 'fake' woman anyhow. None of us can ever get a fucking break...

    [You may subscribe to the trans delusion Ash, but I however do not. If they were actually men, we wouldnt be here now.]

    I am a woman and will be until the day I die now. I have asked you to be respectful toward me -- at the very least, because you get it back.

    I do not believe you have much to lose by admitting that there may be some real transsexuals out there. It would not really invalidate any of your arguments, and it is a viewpoint that allows for chance. Your generalizations tend to be absolute, and I'm sure you are aware that's not how life works.

    [I dont wanna waste my precious time waiting downstairs for you, when you dont show up.]

    I would actually show up to defend her if this were the case. Violence over her expressed ideas is barbaric, as well as hypocritical for any transsexual to espouse.

    [thanks guys for inviting me to get the dirt bitch cunt whore banned. but what we rilly need tado is kill this bitch dead. hope you rot in fucking hell slut!]

    Would you treat a transsexual woman like me this way? Then why do you treat a woman this way? For being opinionated in a manner that you don't like? I think you need to lay off the testosterone, buddy.

    [With all this said, I do want to state that I believe in Transexualism. I have known true transexuals my entire life, and most of these girls aren't.]

    Unfortunately, those like us are lotted right in with their type. Some MtFs are basket cases like them, but there are also highly intelligent, sensible people among our ranks. We don't really deserve to be hated on or excluded by the women we willingly joined.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hi dirt, its interesting because as an australian, id personally never heard of the facebook group.

    Also Aus law and US law are very different, and like you said austrlians need to know this before doing something like this, if you were Australian you would be breaking the law but you are not so you are free to do as you wish.

    as for anon December 16, 2010 10:17 AM and December 16, 2010 10:17 AM

    as a trans person i am disgusted in you, what gives YOU the right to give the rest of us a putrid name, if you have nothing but shit like that to say then dont bother saying any thing at all

    Z

    ReplyDelete
  26. There are decent people who identify as trans out there. The internet population however seems to be a bit insane from what I have seen. The FTMS I've known Ive met in person, at bars, at groups or at specific community meetups. I would like to say, as a transmale identified individual not on T, who does not feel I need T, that I am horribly embarrassed and ashamed of the treatment you are being exposed to from these violent 'FTMs'. We aren't all crazy, or daft.

    I do not relate at ALL to these people or their dimwitted anger. If they really want to get their point across you would think they could at least attempt to spark up a semi-intelligent rhetoric offering their own opinion on the matter.

    While I do not appreciate Dirt's female pronouns for FTM, that does not mean I wish her death or even pain. The only reason a person would attack her is if they question themself. I prefer to be called he, but I cannot and will not force my personal beliefs or lifestyle on anyone. I do not see her wishing death on anyone, she is simply stating her opinion.

    Please do not think FTM are insane, cruel, retarded people.

    PS.. I liked what Dirt wrote after the PS on this post.

    ReplyDelete
  27. [DIRT ALERT spotted dirt at the kroger at 13 and woodward in royal oak, 6pm tonight followed her around for a min said hi she flat out ignored me, maybe because all she had in her basket was about 4 bottles of KY and some powdered eggs..... wtf i need 2 know WHY the FUCKIN powdered eggs?]

    Perhaps she ignored you because you didn't bother to identify yourself? If some stranger greeted me and said nothing else, I'd likely ignore you too. Powdered eggs are often used for baking, because it works the same way and they tend to have a higher nutritional value. They're also popular for camping, because of being non-perishable.

    ReplyDelete
  28. ps Please do not judge all trans people by this ignorance and hate. "

    Thank you for having that in there, Dirt.

    I honestly believe what these guys are doing is embarrassing and ridiculous. I agree with Mike; I too respect your opinion greatly as you help out!

    ReplyDelete
  29. Heh, I bet your local FBI office is having a fun time with your stoopid, paranoid ass. You have some major delusions of grandeur, thinking they would give a crap about some crack-up old dyke who is obsessed with transmen.

    ReplyDelete
  30. The good point is: we have now the list and real names of most opponent to this blog and I have browsed some of their personal pages on Youtube and most of them are just fashion victims, teenager without a rebel cause. Those morons harmful to the silent, respectful, real FTM.

    ReplyDelete
  31. you are aware that you fall under the umbrella term 'transgender' considering you don't conform to the gender binary by being butch?

    ReplyDelete
  32. @dirt 4:47 HAHAHA dirt I've seen you irl and you barely top 5 feet. No doubt just about anyone could whip your butt in 2 minutes flat.

    ReplyDelete
  33. @adindistr

    I am sorry but the way you treat Dirt does not give justice at all at your female XX chromosom and give FTM a bad name as your comment seem to be written by a primate....

    Please stop putting hateful comments here : this blog is not hateful, it gives just another vision of transition.

    I personnaly support it because I do think that this trans fad should end and those girls should go back to other hobbies.

    ReplyDelete
  34. adindistr said...
    "@dirt 4:47 HAHAHA dirt I've seen you irl and you barely top 5 feet. No doubt just about anyone could whip your butt in 2 minutes flat".

    Were that true then what exactly was stopping you?

    At least the anon that said she spotted me in Kroger yesterday was true, with the exception of what was in my cart or her saying hi.

    dirt

    ReplyDelete
  35. I cannot get over how these people are threatening bodily harm, even going to the extent to intimidate by saying they saw dirt in a store, and yet the are upset about "hate speech" and "bullying"!

    Seriously, at this point it's just pure projection--they are doing what they are accusing dirt and her supporters of doing. Where on this blog is there anything resembling the level of threat and wishing of bodily harm in the above comments? Surely, these people cannot be so dense as to think that "misgendering" (as they call it) is tantamount to threatening someone. Sure, they don't *like* to be described by a gendered pronoun that they don't identify with, but that is not the same as stalking and threatening to kill someone!!! The hypocrisy is breathtaking.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Me and my mature trans boyfriend are regular readers of this blog. We are in our 40's and we think that Dirt education work is valuable for the young generation as transition should really be considered after all has been done to avoid it (therapy, support group)...

    My boyfriend started his transition when he was 30 years old and if he had to do it again, he will make the same late mature choice.

    We do think those kids are just teenage rich & spoilt wasp and my boyfriend is ashamed, people may link him in any manner to those morons...

    We don't support in any manner the anger and harassment they do against Dirt. If they want to express themselves, they can do it like grown up in the comments of this blog.

    ReplyDelete
  37. "you are aware that you fall under the umbrella term 'transgender' considering you don't conform to the gender binary by being butch?"

    This, in a nutshell, is why some of us are fed up with trans ideology, trans rhetoric, and academic "gender identity" nonsense. Your personal style and self-presentation, hobbies, interests, and priorities in life do not make you "transgender," no matter how non-stereotypical they may be for your sex.

    ReplyDelete
  38. @dirt 10:27
    I have no desire to kick your butt, that's why. But when I pointed you out to a friend of mine, he sure wanted to. I talked him out of it. It's not worth getting into trouble over you. You definitely deserve to have your butt beat, though, for posting images and other screen caps without permission.

    ReplyDelete
  39. adindistr,

    If you or any trans person you know actually saw me somewhere, there isnt a single one of you's who would have the guts to speak to me let alone start an "ass kickin"...lol Hello!

    And the next midget size woman you encounter in a store wishing it were me? You best keep looking for the real me hun, cuz I'd hate to see you not only get your ass whipped by some little lady, it'd be a shame to see you wind up in jail on top of your yougotyourasskicked mistake in identity....or not!

    dirt

    ReplyDelete
  40. http://ko-kr.connect.facebook.com/pages/FCK-DIRT/122159774488748

    I guess this is another one?
    IF, as they say, "gender doesn't matter that much", then why do they think this blog is *hate crime*?

    ReplyDelete
  41. Blue,

    They believe by silencing me they can silence the voice of reason in their own heads.

    dirt

    ReplyDelete
  42. Hey dirt.

    I want to apologize on behalf of some of my fellow trans brothers. I find your blog interesting and I like seeing things from a different perspective. We can agree to disagree on things and still be civil to one another. There is not reason to be hateful to one another for disagreeing on something. I apologize for the number of threats you have received from the trans community for sharing your opinions about transitioning. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions.

    I sincerely wish you well and much happiness.

    ReplyDelete
  43. I had a look at the Page reported above (the F*CK Dirt page) and here is what is written "FUCK DIRT is dedicated to showing support and love for the Trans community in the face of hatred and bringing down the disgusting paternalistic transphobic blog "the dirt from Dirt". HATE is HATE."

    I think those FTM are morons: they are the ones that celebrate a paternalist vision of society. Everyone who has read 5 min of blog post, will get that her blog is a feminist blog, against mysoginy and paternalism...

    Those young FTM are not only on T, do not have only their boob removed but also apparently they were lobotomised to the point they just don't get they see parternalism everyday in their mirror...

    I do support Dirt blog and don't find it transphobic or hateful. We as member of the LGBTQI have the right to question queer theory, have the right to fight for women/lesbian representation and spaces, have the right to say we do not agree and to warn people about this dangerous fad of trans fashionistas...I will never let Dirt being silenced by those spoilt kids who need a target for their violence. Silencing Dirt means silencing all women and I will fight against it !

    ReplyDelete
  44. [Those young FTM are not only on T, do not have only their boob removed but also apparently they were lobotomised to the point they just don't get they see parternalism everyday in their mirror...]

    Nah, not lobotimized; it is basic male socialization, very rudimentary. Like somebody who only has an outside understanding of what a man tends to act like, and is doing their best to emulate what they think it is all about. The sharp contrast of behavior between these younger punks and respectable FTM gentlemen is plainly obvious.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Wow, just wow. I just read the post and think it is digusting. I don't think that there is anything wrong with this blog or Dirt's message. As a proud, out Butch-loving Femme, I fully support her.

    I tried to find the event, so I could report it. But I didn't see it, so I am thinking it's gone now.

    ReplyDelete
  46. And to Ash, who said "how the fuck would you feel if a femme started a blog saying that all butch lesbians aren't real women cause they want to dress like men and have short haircuts..."

    A real Femme would never even think of doing something so vile and terrible. We stand beside Butches and acknowledge their struggles and support them.

    ReplyDelete
  47. In addition to reporting the F*ck Dirt Page, I also reported anyone who posted on its wall as personally attacking me or a friend. (And Dirt is a friend to all Lesbians.)

    ReplyDelete
  48. Anon@9:29am

    This "queer" group/kids knows absolutely about NOTHING about Butch/Femme or how we function.

    dirt

    ReplyDelete

Copyright © The dirt from Dirt | Powered by Blogger
Design by SimpleWpThemes | Blogger Theme by NewBloggerThemes.com | Distributed By Blogger Templates20